The short answer

Quick answer. Buy a juicing recipe book if you own a juicer and want drinks with the fiber removed; buy a blender recipe book if you own a blender and want drinks with the fiber kept, which are thicker and need a bigger glass. The two differ in produce per glass: our juicer recipes use about 55.2 g of produce per fl oz of drink and our blender recipes 33.4 g, so a juice costs more produce per sip. Check which equipment a book assumes before you buy.

Produce per glass: juice against blend

The main practical difference is how much produce a glass takes. Juicing removes the pulp, so it takes more produce for the same volume. The table uses our recipe data: total ingredient grams divided by the yield estimate, for all 10 juicer recipes and 2 blender recipes.

From our recipe data: yield estimates are from published tables (juice) or 1 g = 1 ml (blend). 'at least' recipes with unsourced yields are included as stated, so the juice figure is a ceiling.
Juicer recipesBlender recipes
Recipes in our data102
Produce per fl oz of drink55.2 g33.4 g
Food per serving374 g364 g
FiberMostly removedKept (unless strained)
TextureThinThick
EquipmentJuicer, or blender plus strainerAny blender

A juice recipe also needs a way to deal with pulp, and cleaning a juicer takes longer than rinsing a blender cup. Neither is better; they make different drinks.

Match the book to your equipment

Our reading of how to match a book to equipment.
You ownLook forCheck
A juicer onlyA juicing bookWeights, chute-friendly cuts, pulp uses
A blender onlyA blender bookLiquid amounts, order of loading, thin versions
BothA book with both methodsThat each recipe gives a method for each
NeitherA free recipe firstThat you will keep going before you buy gear

Many of our own recipes give both: a juicer method and a blender method with a strainer, so you can start with what you have. See our recipes.

Decide in four steps

  1. Write down your equipment.
  2. Look at sample pages for the amounts and method.
  3. Check how it treats fiber. A blender book that claims a smoothie 'replaces' a juice, or the reverse, is overreaching.
  4. Check the claims and sources, as in the buying guide.

The juicer vs blender guide covers the machine choice, which usually comes before the book.

What the numbers do not say

The table does not say which drink is healthier, and we make no such claim. Juice removes fiber and keeps sugar; a blended drink keeps both. People managing blood sugar should ask a doctor and prefer vegetable-heavy recipes either way. This is general information; see our recipe disclaimer.

Cleaning and time in the two methods

A blender recipe is faster to clean: one jar and a rinse. A juicer has several parts and a screen, and pulp to deal with. In our recipe data, a juicer recipe takes about 12 to 20 minutes in total and a blender recipe about 8 to 15, from prep to finish; check each recipe page for its own minutes. If time is the limit, a blender book fits a busy morning, and a juicing book fits a longer session.

Sources: Our recipe data (recipes.json); Kuvings, produce per cup of juice (yield estimates).