The short answer

Quick answer. Manual citrus juicers (a press or a reamer) cost less, take little space and are enough for up to about six fruits at a time. Electric citrus juicers (a motorised reamer) are quicker and easier on the hands once you squeeze more than about a dozen, but have more parts and a cord. Decide by batch size: a cup of lemon juice takes 6 to 8 medium lemons, so a pitcher of lemonade is the point where electric starts to pay.

Batch size decides it

The work of juicing citrus is a count of halves. This table uses our lemon data (two sources) to show how many lemons and halves four common batch sizes need, and the tool that fits.

Computed from our citrus data (USDA FDC and NDSU extension). The 'fit' column is our judgement of effort, not a test.
Juice neededMedium lemons (fewest to most)Halves to squeezeFit
2 fl oz (59 ml)24Manual is fine
4 fl oz (118 ml)3 to 46 to 8Manual is fine
8 fl oz (237 ml)6 to 812 to 16Either; electric saves effort
16 fl oz (473 ml)11 to 1622 to 32Electric or lever press

At up to about six lemons a manual press is quick. Past a dozen halves a hand tool tires the wrist, which is where an electric reamer or a lever press earns its place. Limes scale about the same way: USDA's single figure is 44 g of juice per lime against 48 g per lemon.

What each type does well

Our reading of the two types in general terms, not a test of any model. The makers of electric reamers give figures we have not confirmed, so we use none.
Manual (press or reamer)Electric reamer
Price and storageLow; fits a drawerHigher; needs counter or cupboard space
EffortHand strength; grows with batch sizeLow: press and hold
SpeedA minute for a few fruitsFaster for many fruits
CleaningOne or two partsCone, strainer, bowl and body
Noise and powerSilent, no cordMotor noise; needs an outlet
Fruit sizesPress: sized to the cup; reamer: any halfUsually one cone for most sizes; check large fruit

The comparison does not depend on a brand. We have not read a maker page for a named citrus juicer, so this page names none.

Choose in five steps

  1. Write down the biggest batch you make and use the table to count the fruit.
  2. If it is six lemons or fewer, buy a manual press or reamer and stop there.
  3. If it is a dozen or more, or you squeeze most days, look at an electric reamer or a lever press.
  4. Check the cleaning parts count and whether the strainer lifts out.
  5. Check storage: an electric one that lives in a cupboard gets used less than one on the counter.

If you mostly juice greens with the occasional lemon, a manual press is all the citrus tool you need; see press vs reamer. For a lemon-and-lime comparison, see that guide.

Using a regular juicer instead

A regular juicer will juice peeled citrus, but a dedicated tool is simpler: a slow or fast juicer needs the fruit peeled and cut, which takes more time than halving and pressing. If your juicer is the main tool and you add a lemon half to each batch, our recipes peel the lemon and feed it in. See the comparison guide and the citrus juicers hub.

Sources: USDA FoodData Central, lemon juice (via our citrus data); NDSU Extension FN198; Our citrus juice calculator.