The short answer

Quick answer. For margaritas you squeeze many limes, so the best citrus juicer is the one that does a dozen limes without tiring you or leaving juice behind: a hand-operated lever press or an electric reamer for a party, a handheld press for two drinks. At the assumed 1 fl oz of lime juice per drink, four drinks need 4 fl oz, which is about 3 medium limes. The lime yield is a single USDA source, so buy a few extra.

How many limes you need

Everything else follows from the lime count. A margarita recipe varies in how much lime it uses, so we assume 1 fl oz (about 30 ml) of lime juice per drink; change the figure for your recipe. A medium lime gives about 1.5 fl oz (single USDA FoodData Central source: 44 g of juice per fruit), and fruit that is smaller or drier gives less.

Computed from our citrus data (one USDA FDC source for lime; no second source). 'Most' assumes drier fruit. Assumption: 1 fl oz of lime juice per drink.
DrinksLime juice at 1 fl oz eachMedium limes (fewest to most)
22 fl oz (59 ml)2
44 fl oz (118 ml)3
66 fl oz (177 ml)5
88 fl oz (237 ml)6
1212 fl oz (355 ml)9

Always buy a few more than the high end. Limes vary a lot in juiciness, and a lime that has sat in the fridge gives less. Our citrus juice calculator lets you change the amount and the fruit size.

Press, reamer or electric: which for how many

The right tool depends on how many limes, not on price.

Our reading of how each tool scales, not a test.
BatchBest fitWhy
1 to 4 drinks (1 to 4 limes)Handheld press or hand reamerQuick, one tool to wash
6 to 12 drinks (5 to 12 limes)Lever press or electric reamerLess wrist effort per lime
A pitcher or partyElectric reamer or a lever press with a large cupSpeed matters; keep a strainer for pulp and seeds

See handheld press vs manual reamer and manual vs electric for how to choose between them.

Juicing limes for drinks, step by step

  1. Wash the limes under running water and scrub the peel; the peel touches the juice and your hands.
  2. Roll each lime on the counter under your palm to break up the interior before cutting.
  3. Cut in half across the middle, not through the ends, so each half sits in the cup.
  4. Press or ream each half, flat side down in a press, until it stops giving juice.
  5. Strain out seeds and pulp and use the juice the same day; refrigerate it if you wait, and drink it soon.

Fresh lime juice is not pasteurized. If you serve it to people who are pregnant, young, older or have a weakened immune system, follow FDA's juice safety advice. Alcohol is outside what we cover here.

What to look for in the juicer

  • A cup or press that fits a lime. Limes are about 2 in (51 mm) across by USDA's portion size, smaller than most lemons, so check the press cup is not oversized.
  • A strainer you can lift out. Seeds and pulp collect there.
  • Few parts. You will wash it between batches.
  • A pour spout or a juice cup you can pour from.

For a lime-and-lemon tool that also does lemons, read how to choose for lemons and limes, and the citrus juicers hub.

Sources: USDA FoodData Central, lime juice (via our citrus data); Our citrus juice calculator; FDA, juice safety.