The short answer

Quick answer. Choose a personal blender if you make one or two smoothies and want the cup to double as your drinking cup; choose a countertop blender if you make three or more servings, soups or sauces. At a three-quarters fill, a 24 fl oz personal cup makes 1 servings of our green smoothie; a 64 fl oz jar makes 4. The countertop blender takes more room and more cleaning; the personal blender needs more rounds for a family.

How many servings each makes

The difference is batch size. This table uses our two blender recipes as the test: serving sizes from our recipe data, and a three-quarters fill, which is our assumption (check each machine's max line).

Capacities are sizes commonly sold, not a named model. Recipe serving sizes are our yield estimates.
SizeCapacityUsable (75%)Servings of green smoothie (10 fl oz)Servings of green lemonade (12 fl oz)
Personal cup24 fl oz (710 ml)18 fl oz11
Personal cup (large)32 fl oz (946 ml)24 fl oz22
Countertop jar48 fl oz (1420 ml)36 fl oz33
Countertop jar (large)64 fl oz (1893 ml)48 fl oz44

A personal cup makes one or two servings; a large jar makes four or more. If you make a smoothie for two every morning, a 32 fl oz cup is the minimum; for a family, the jar saves rounds.

Compare on six points

Our reading of the two types in general terms, not a test of any model.
Personal blenderCountertop blender
Servings per run1 to 23 to 6
Drinking cupThe blending cup, with a to-go lidSeparate glass; pour
CleaningCup, blade assembly and gasketJar, lid, blade and tamper
Counter spaceSmallLarger and taller
Soups, sauces, nut buttersUsually notMore often yes, check the maker
Frozen fruitDepends on the base; checkMore often handles it; check

For the next step up, see the high-speed blenders hub; for the small end, portable blenders.

Decide in four steps

  1. Count servings per day. One or two: personal. Three or more: countertop.
  2. Check the drinks. Smoothies only: personal is enough. Soups and sauces: countertop.
  3. Check the space. Measure the shelf, including the height with the jar on.
  4. Think about washing. You will rinse a personal cup more often but it takes seconds; a jar takes longer but less often.

For one person, our one-person guide shows the weekly produce. If you are torn between a blender and a juicer, read juicer vs blender.

Cost of ownership, without prices

We do not quote prices, because they change daily. Compare the things that last: spare parts (a spare cup, blade or jar and gasket), the length of the maker's warranty and how many parts you must wash. A countertop jar costs more to replace than a personal cup. Check, too, that the maker sells the part you are most likely to break, usually the gasket or the blade assembly. A blender you can repair is worth more than one you must replace.

Sources: Our recipe data (yield estimates); Unit conversion: 1 US fl oz = 29.5735 ml.