The short answer

Quick answer. Juice is thin and works with almost any lid; a smoothie is thick and needs a wide straw or a wide sip opening, and a larger cup for ice and headroom. Our blended recipes keep the fiber and are thick; our juiced recipes remove most of it and pour easily. Pick a cup of 16 to 20 fl oz for one serving of either, with a lid that closes, and check the cup is easy to clean with a straw brush.

Thin or thick: what your recipe needs

Whether a drink is thin or thick depends on whether the fiber was removed. This table sets five of our recipes against the lid and straw they suit.

Textures from how each recipe is made (blend-all or juiced), serving sizes from our recipe data (estimates). Straw advice is our reading.
RecipeTextureOne servingLid and straw
Basic green juiceJuiced: thin14 fl ozStandard straw or sip lid
Ginger shotsJuiced: thin2 fl ozStandard straw or sip lid
Green smoothieBlended, with fiber: thick10 fl ozWide straw or wide sip opening
Celery juiceJuiced: thin9 fl ozStandard straw or sip lid
Green lemonadeJuiced: thin12 fl ozStandard straw or sip lid

A wide straw or a sip lid with a large opening suits the smoothie; a narrow straw clogs. The shot recipe needs a small bottle, not a cup.

Check the cup in five steps

  1. Size. 16 fl oz for most servings; 20 fl oz if you add ice.
  2. Lid. A sip lid for juice; a wide sip or wide straw lid for a smoothie. Test it upside down over a sink.
  3. Straw. A wide straw (about the width of a finger) for a smoothie; check it comes out for washing.
  4. Cleaning. Seals and straws are the problem parts; look for a removable seal and a brush that fits.
  5. Fit. Check the base against your cupholder; see the cupholder guide.

For more on keeping a drink cold, see insulation explained.

Materials for each drink

Our reading in general terms, not a test.
MaterialGood forWatch for
Stainless steelCold smoothies you carry; often insulatedCannot see inside; dents
PlasticLight; juice on the goStains from carrot and beet; holds smells
GlassDesk or homeHeavy; breakable

Smoothie residue dries hard on seals and straws. Rinse right after drinking, fill a third with warm soapy water and shake, and use a straw brush. See the travel cups hub for the cleaning routine.

Carrying and drinking safely

Homemade juice and smoothies are not pasteurized and have no official storage time. Keep them cold and drink them soon, as our storage guide explains. Do not put hot drinks in a cup built for cold, and do not leave a drink in a warm car. Wash the lid and straw each day.

Reading a capacity claim

Cup capacity on a box can be the brim volume, which includes the space above the max line, so a 20 fl oz cup may hold 16 fl oz of drink. Look for the fill line, and compare it with the serving in the table. For a smoothie, allow extra: it foams when shaken, and ice displaces drink. If a cup lists its dimensions, check the height too: tall narrow cups are hard to clean with a short brush, and wide ones may not fit a cupholder.

Sources: Our recipe data (yield estimates); FDA, juice safety.