The short answer

Quick answer. Choose a wide-mouth bottle if you fill it from a juicer spout or a jug, add ice, ginger slices or fruit, or clean it with a brush; choose a narrow mouth if you carry it and drink straight from it. Measure the opening you need: a 1 in (25 mm) ginger slice or ice cube needs a mouth wider than that, and a small apple at 2.75 in (70 mm) needs a mouth wider than that to drop in. A mouth too narrow for a brush is hard to clean.

What fits through the mouth

USDA lists diameters for some produce in its portion data, so you can see how wide a mouth must be to take it whole. The table shows widths in inches and millimetres; measure your bottle's opening inside the neck, since the outside is wider.

From USDA FoodData Central portion labels (ginger slices, strawberries, lime, kiwi, apple); the ice cube is not listed. Measure your own bottle.
ItemDiameterIn millimetres
Ginger slice (1 in)1 in25 mm
Strawberry, large1.375 in35 mm
Lime2 in51 mm
Kiwi2 in51 mm
Apple, small2.75 in70 mm

Most juice does not need a wide mouth for produce, since it goes in the juicer first. The mouth matters for what you add afterwards: ice, ginger, lemon wedges or chopped fruit in an infused drink.

Wide against narrow, on five points

Our reading in general terms, not a test of any bottle.
Wide mouthNarrow mouth
Filling from a juicer spoutEasyNeeds a funnel
Ice and ginger slicesFitDo not fit
CleaningA brush or hand reaches the bottomNeeds a long, thin brush
Drinking on the goSplashes; can spillControlled flow
LidsLarger lids, often more partsSmaller, simpler lids

A wide mouth is easier to use at home; a narrow mouth is easier in a car or at a desk.

Choose in four steps

  1. Decide where you fill it. At a juicer spout, wide is easier.
  2. Decide whether you add ice or fruit. If yes, wide.
  3. Check the brush. A narrow bottle needs a brush that reaches the base; see brush types.
  4. Think about carrying. If it travels, check the lid; see lid types.

A pour spout or a funnel solves most of the narrow-mouth filling problem. For material, read glass vs plastic.

Cleaning either shape

Rinse straight after emptying, then wash with hot soapy water and a bottle brush. For a narrow neck, a long brush with a flexible head reaches the base; for a wide mouth, a hand and sponge will do. Dry upside down, and leave the lid off. A spoon of baking soda in warm water removes odour. The bottles hub has more on cleaning and sizes.

Measure your own bottle

Mouth width is rarely on the box. Measure the inside of the opening with a ruler across the widest point of the neck, in millimetres. Compare it with the table: a 25 mm opening takes a ginger slice or an ice cube on its side, and a 70 mm opening takes a small apple whole. Check the lid at the same time; a wide mouth often has a lid that unscrews in two pieces, with a seal to wash. Write the width on the bottle's base with a marker if you own several.

Sources: USDA FoodData Central (portion sizes); Our bottles hub.