The short answer

Quick answer. Glass and plastic bottles both work for juice; they differ in weight, staining and breakage. Glass does not stain or hold smells and is easy to see clean, but it is heavy and can break. Plastic is light and rarely breaks but can stain and hold odours. Most of our green juices contain nothing that stains strongly, so for green juice the real choice is weight against breakage; our table shows which recipes carry staining ingredients.

Which of our recipes stain

Staining depends on what is in the bottle. Beet, carrot and berries tint plastic over time; green produce does less. This table checks every recipe in our data against that short list and shows which are most likely to mark a plastic bottle.

From our recipe data; our list of staining produce is beet, carrot, ginger, tomato, turmeric and berries. A reading, not a test.
RecipeStaining produce in itPlastic risk
Basic green juicegingerMay tint plastic
Ginger shotsgingerMay tint plastic
Green smoothienoneLow risk
Celery juicenoneLow risk
Wheatgrass juicenoneLow risk
Cucumber juicenoneLow risk
Kale juicecarrotMay tint plastic
Spinach juicenoneLow risk
Mean green juicegingerMay tint plastic
Low-sugar green juicegingerMay tint plastic
Green lemonadenoneLow risk
Watermelon rind green juicegingerMay tint plastic

If your juices are green, staining matters less. If you drink beet or carrot juice often, glass saves you from a pink bottle.

Glass against plastic on five points

Our reading of the materials in general terms, not a test of any bottle.
GlassPlastic
WeightHeavyLight
BreakageCan chip or breakRarely; can crack or warp
Stains and odoursResists bothCan hold both
CleaningEasy to see clean; handles hot waterCheck the maker for heat limits
CarryingNeeds a sleeve in a bagFine in a bag

Where a plastic bottle claims to be BPA-free or a glass bottle heat-safe, look for it on the maker's page. We repeat no maker claims.

Decide in four steps

  1. Where does it travel? Home fridge: glass. Gym bag or commute: plastic, or glass in a sleeve.
  2. What goes in it? Beet and carrot: glass. Green juice: either.
  3. How will you wash it? A wide mouth cleans easier; see wide vs narrow.
  4. Check the lid, since it is the part that leaks; see lid types.

For storing chopped produce rather than juice, read glass vs plastic storage; for the number of bottles, how many you need. See the bottles hub.

Safety and care

Homemade juice is not pasteurized and has no official storage time; keep it cold, fill the bottle to the top and drink it soon. Do not freeze a full glass bottle, since the liquid expands; leave an inch of headspace or use a freezer-rated container. Wash with hot soapy water and a bottle brush, and dry upside down. Replace plastic that is scratched, cloudy or smelly, and glass that is chipped.

Weight when full

A bottle adds its own weight to the juice. A 16 fl oz bottle holds about 473 g of juice (1 ml is about 1 g), so a full bottle is about a pound before the bottle; glass can add another few hundred grams. For a daily bag, that matters; for a fridge shelf it does not. If you carry two bottles, the difference is noticeable. We found no confirmed maker weights, so weigh the bottle you are considering on a kitchen scale before you decide.

Sources: Our recipe data; FDA, juice safety.