The short answer

Quick answer. For chopped produce, glass is better if you want no odour or stain and will keep the lid on a tight gasket; plastic is better if you carry it or drop things. Whatever the material, what matters more is the prep: dry it, line the box with a paper towel, and keep leaves separate and loosely packed. Cut apple and pear only just before juicing, since they brown. We give no storage day count for cut produce.

What to cut ahead and what not to

Some produce stores well cut and some does not. The material of the container matters less than that. This table shows how we would store each item from our recipes, a reading and not a test.

Our reading; browning list: apple, pear, banana, avocado, peach. Not a test or a shelf-life figure.
ProduceHow to store itContainer
CeleryCut ahead, dry, paper towel in the boxEither; glass resists odour
Cucumber (with peel)Cut ahead, dry, paper towel in the boxEither; glass resists odour
CarrotCut ahead, dry, paper towel in the boxEither; glass resists odour
BeetCut ahead, dry, paper towel in the boxEither; glass resists odour
Apple (with skin)Cut just before juicing; it brownsEither; glass resists odour
SpinachWash and dry; store whole leaf, loose, with a paper towelGlass or plastic with a loose fill
KaleWash and dry; store whole leaf, loose, with a paper towelGlass or plastic with a loose fill
Lemon (whole, without peel)Store whole; peel when juicingEither; glass resists odour
Ginger rootCut ahead, dry, paper towel in the boxEither; glass resists odour

For how many containers and what sizes, see the container sizes guide.

Glass against plastic for produce

Our reading of the materials in general terms, not a test of any container.
GlassPlastic
Smell and stainResists both; ginger and onion do not lingerCan hold smells and tint from carrot and beet
Weight in the fridgeHeavy to stackLight
LidsGasket lids; wash the gasketSnap lids; can warp in a dishwasher
FreezingOnly freezer-rated; leave headspaceOften fine; check the maker
Seeing what is insideYesOften yes
BreakageChips and cracksRarely

Pack a box in five steps

  1. Wash under running water, scrub firm items, no soap.
  2. Dry thoroughly. Wet produce goes slimy faster.
  3. Line the box with a paper towel to absorb moisture.
  4. Pack loosely, leaves especially; crushed leaves spoil.
  5. Label with the date and use the oldest first.

Keep cut produce cold, as FDA advises, and discard anything slimy or off-smelling. Juice you make from it is not pasteurized; see the storage guide.

When to choose which

  • Weekly prep at home: glass, with a gasket lid.
  • Lunch box or commute: plastic, or glass in a sleeve.
  • Strong smells such as ginger or onion: glass.
  • Freezing: a freezer-rated container of either material, with headspace.

For bottles, see glass vs plastic bottles, and the hub.

Odour and cross-flavour

Ginger, onion and herbs scent a plastic box for weeks. If you prep ginger and celery together in one plastic container, the celery can pick up the ginger flavour. Glass resists it, but a lid with a gasket can still hold smell. Give ginger and herbs their own small container, and wash gaskets by hand. A paste of baking soda and water removes lingering smell from plastic lids.

Sources: FDA, Selecting and serving produce safely; Our recipe data and produce data.