The short answer

Quick answer. A balanced green juice has four parts by weight: a watery base (cucumber or celery) for half or more, leafy greens for a tenth to a fifth, a little fruit for sweetness and a small amount of lemon and ginger to lift the taste. In our six example recipes the base is 36 to 89 percent of the weight, leaves 2 to 21 percent and fruit 0 to 36 percent. Build by weight, taste, then change one thing at a time.

The formula in our own recipes

The table shows how six of our juicer recipes divide their ingredient weight between five groups. It is the quickest way to see what balance means in practice.

Percent of total ingredient weight, from our recipe data (recipes.json). Groups come from the produce data: vegetables (cucumber, celery, carrot, beet), greens and herbs, fruit, citrus, ginger.
RecipeBase vegetablesLeaves and herbsFruitCitrusGinger
Basic green juice62%4%27%5%2%
Mean green juice50%8%34%7%2%
Low-sugar green juice75%15%0%8%2%
Spinach juice48%19%28%5%0%
Kale juice36%21%36%7%0%
Cucumber juice89%2%0%10%0%

Notice the pattern. Cucumber and celery carry most of the weight because they are juicy and mild. Leaves are only 2 to 21 percent, because they are light and give little juice. Fruit is none in the low-sugar and cucumber recipes and about a third in the sweet ones. Citrus is 5 to 10 percent and ginger 2 percent or none, yet they set the taste.

Build a juice in five steps

  1. Pick a base: half the weight or more. Cucumber, celery or both. They are mild and give the most juice per pound in our planner table.
  2. Add leaves: a tenth to a fifth. Spinach, romaine or kale. Vary them, and read the safety notes on vitamin K.
  3. Add fruit for sweetness: a handful. A green apple or pear; more fruit means more sugar, which our recipe pages show per serving.
  4. Add acid and spice: a few percent. Half a lemon peeled; five slices of ginger.
  5. Taste and adjust one thing. Too bitter: more fruit or lemon. Too sweet: more cucumber. Too flat: more lemon.

Write down the grams, not the cups, so you can repeat it. Cup weights vary a lot, as a cup of chopped celery weighs about 101 g and a cup of spinach about 30 g.

Fixing the common problems

Our reading of common balance problems.
ProblemLikely causeFix
BitterToo many bitter greens (kale, parsley, dandelion)Add apple or lemon; swap some kale for spinach or romaine
Too sweetToo much fruitReplace apple with cucumber; see our low-sugar recipe
Thin and wateryAll cucumber and no leavesAdd leaves or celery
Sharp and hotToo much gingerCut the ginger by half
Grassy and flatNo acidAdd lemon

For a deeper look at bitterness, read why green juice tastes bitter. For ginger, see how to use ginger.

Keeping the sugar in check

Juice keeps the sugar and loses most of the fiber, so people managing blood sugar should favour vegetable-heavy, low-fruit recipes and ask their doctor. Our low-sugar green juice is the example: it has about 6 g of sugars per serving by our calculation, against 25 to 29 g for the sweet recipes. The planner shows the figures for the week. This is general information, not medical advice.

Sources: Our recipe data (recipes.json, produce.json); USDA FoodData Central; Kuvings, produce per cup of juice.